Home - Back

Or, humbled...

- [Previous Topic] [Next Topic]
#6133 [2004-12-06 14:12:19]

Or, humbled...

by yeomanforbes

It's interesting how humble you can feel when walking amidst
thousands upon thousands of books. I wandered through the history
section of the lovely and art endowed Los Angeles County Central
Library (http://www.lapl.org/central/art_architecture.html) which
was organized by country/region, and/or individual, and went from
the tumultous Koreans right into Japan. One moment, it's all this
north-south damn-those-chinese-and-americans kind of talk, the next,
there's twigs and blossoms and peace. Well, that's how it started,
but it soon grew ugly as the section broadened into warfare.
Warfare, art, warfare, art... I understand you can study both, but
it seemed a curious mixture to have them interspaced. There was a
theme here, but I couldn't quite lay my finger on it. (Of course,
going back a bit in the Korea section revealed that they, too,
shared no love of the Japanese, probably due to the twice a millenia
invasions by those folks. What is so wonderful about Korea that the
Japanese kept invading it?)

So I snagged Mr. Turnbull's Osprey book and "Samurai, A Military
History," also by that same worthy, and found that the Osprey book
was meaty reading for such a thin tome. I suspect, from Turnbull's
many offerings, that he is an excellent gent to start with, and then
to branch out when my abundant free time is no longer taken up by
these books. Suggestions, anyone? (Or, if there's a reading list
compiled by some person, kindly direct me to it?)

After picking up those volumes, I wandered some more, and mused on
the fact that someone, somewhere, for some reason completely unknown
to me, thinks it important that we preserve the 1964 yellow pages
for Des Moines, Iowa. Else, why have it available for checkout, in
a library created ugly brown cover, with black lettering? If only
Andrew could see his progeny now, and think, "for this, I ruthlessly
crushed all other steel companies?" Ah, but the rest of the place!
It was enough to humble your kind author. I know so very little
about anything. Soon, I will know a very little about this subject,
too. :)

Cheers.

[Next #6136]

#6136 [2004-12-06 16:00:20]

Re: [samuraihistory] Or, humbled...

by ltdomer98

--- Matt <yeomanforbes@...> wrote:

What is so wonderful
> about Korea that the
> Japanese kept invading it?

Nothing. And I say that having lived their twice. It's
a 2 way road between Japan and the Asian
mainland--nobody in their right mind would invade
Korea simply to own that....place. If Japan owns it,
they control any Asian movement towards their country,
and can move into Asia. Same thing for the Chinese,
Russians, etc...

> So I snagged Mr. Turnbull's Osprey book and
> "Samurai, A Military
> History," also by that same worthy, and found that
> the Osprey book
> was meaty reading for such a thin tome.

Which Osprey book? He's got about 20 of them.

I suspect,
> from Turnbull's
> many offerings, that he is an excellent gent to
> start with, and then
> to branch out when my abundant free time is no
> longer taken up by
> these books. Suggestions, anyone? (Or, if there's
> a reading list
> compiled by some person, kindly direct me to it?)

Once again: www.samuraiarchives.com

One note of warning about Turnbull: He's mercurial,
and often times concerned with publication for
publication's sake. Much of his newer books are
rehashes of things he'd previously written, and some
are horribly edited. Many of his older books contain
numerous mistakes, some of which he has later
corrected. Questions have arisen about his "research"
in earlier books since they mirror other books by less
prolific authors.

He's a good place to start, and some of his books are
fabulous: Samurai Invasion, Samurai Warriors, Samurai
Warlords, to name a few. In other ways, he simply
cashes in on what he can: Japanese Warfare from 1467;
Ninja (how can you say that ninja didn't walk around
in black pajamas, then have every picture in the book
be of a skulking sneak in black pajamas?), etc.

My own recommendations would be:

George Sansom's series: dated, some places inaccurate,
but the best overall overview of Japanese history out
there for under $500.

Mary Berry--Hideyoshi

Anthony J. Bryant (I'm not his agent, but should be).






__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - 250MB free storage. Do more. Manage less.
http://info.mail.yahoo.com/mail_250

[Previous #6133]


Made with