Home - Back

Re: Toledo swords - veering OT at a dangerous rate

- [Previous Topic] [Next Topic]
#6204 [2004-12-09 23:37:23]

RE: [samuraihistory] Toledo swords - veering OT at a dangerous rate

by geregjonesmuller

Gabriel -
This in answer to both your note here and to a respondent who came along
later: over the past thirty years I've handled a number of blades made in
Toledo, both good ones and bad, and I'll assure you that this site is simply
using the name of the city. I have no doubt at all that the smiths of
Toledo in Spain are still forging fine blades, as they have been doing for
hundreds of years... and I also do not doubt that some of them are
simultaneously turning out pieces of wall-hanger pot-metal for tourists'
walls. All the same, I'd hate to see anyone's opinion of Toledo blades,
which can be very fine indeed, shaped by this fairly standard selection of
pop-steel. Feel free to contact me off-list if you'd like a few better
places to look.
And on the other hand, anyone who has contact information for any of the
smiths of Toledo, please feel free to contact me also.
Gereg

Message: 8
Date: Thu, 09 Dec 2004 10:19:15 -0000
From: "Dodu Gabriel" <dodu_gabriel@...>
Subject: Re: Japan Eras



--- In samuraihistory@yahoogroups.com, Nate Ledbetter
wrote:
>
> Were you interested, we do have a few sword experts
> (I'm not one of them). Swords can be cool as long as
> you don't get all freaky.
>
> Nate
>
Thank you, Nate, I am interested in swords, can't say that I'm not.
I don't know much, so an expert's opinion would be most welcome. I
like the www.toledoswords.com site, mostly because it's one of the
few I have visited (so I only know about their opinion). Is it ok?
Oh, and don't be afraid, as I have no intention on getting freaky, I
just like to learn about the historical events that have taken place
throughout the world, and in that matter the Discovery Channel has
been of great help ;)
I am also very interested in sailships, but that does not make the
object of this forum, so sorry I've mentioned it.

Respectfully,

Gabriel

[Next #6208]

#6208 [2004-12-10 00:58:19]

Re: Toledo swords - veering OT at a dangerous rate

by dodu_gabriel

Hello Gereg,

I'm sorry I rushed to write about that site, because on further
examination, I have discovered that it is a fake. My mistake...Thank
you for helping me and tell me what do you think of this site:
www.jidai.jp, although I'm having difficulties at this time buying a
300 Euros sword...So the site is just a dream, besides, since I don't
take any Kendo or any alike, I wouldn't know what to do with a sword,
but to admire its beauty.

Sorry again, and I hope I have redeemed myself in your eyes :)

Respectfully,

Gabriel


--- In samuraihistory@yahoogroups.com, "Silk Road School"
wrote:
>
> Gabriel -
> This in answer to both your note here and to a respondent who came
along
> later: over the past thirty years I've handled a number of blades
made in
> Toledo, both good ones and bad, and I'll assure you that this site
is simply
> using the name of the city. I have no doubt at all that the smiths
of
> Toledo in Spain are still forging fine blades, as they have been
doing for
> hundreds of years... and I also do not doubt that some of them are
> simultaneously turning out pieces of wall-hanger pot-metal for
tourists'
> walls. All the same, I'd hate to see anyone's opinion of Toledo
blades,
> which can be very fine indeed, shaped by this fairly standard
selection of
> pop-steel. Feel free to contact me off-list if you'd like a few
better
> places to look.
> And on the other hand, anyone who has contact information for any
of the
> smiths of Toledo, please feel free to contact me also.
> Gereg
>
> Message: 8
> Date: Thu, 09 Dec 2004 10:19:15 -0000
> From: "Dodu Gabriel"
> Subject: Re: Japan Eras
>
>
>
> --- In samuraihistory@yahoogroups.com, Nate Ledbetter
> wrote:
> >
> > Were you interested, we do have a few sword experts
> > (I'm not one of them). Swords can be cool as long as
> > you don't get all freaky.
> >
> > Nate
> >
> Thank you, Nate, I am interested in swords, can't say that I'm not.
> I don't know much, so an expert's opinion would be most welcome. I
> like the www.toledoswords.com site, mostly because it's one of the
> few I have visited (so I only know about their opinion). Is it ok?
> Oh, and don't be afraid, as I have no intention on getting freaky,
I
> just like to learn about the historical events that have taken place
> throughout the world, and in that matter the Discovery Channel has
> been of great help ;)
> I am also very interested in sailships, but that does not make the
> object of this forum, so sorry I've mentioned it.
>
> Respectfully,
>
> Gabriel

[Previous #6204]


Made with