> I view the ninja somewhere between 'militaryThat strikes me as fairly accurate. And as far as MI
> intelligence' (I
> know those with a military background often doubt
> that such a
> thing exists) and 'special ops'.
>There may have been intel/counterintell involved (GOD
> Reading 'between the lines', did not the run-up to
> Nagashino
> involve a plot to betray the Tokugawa from within?
> Presumably
> Takeda 'ninja' were working the subversion
> operation, and
> Tokugawa 'ninja' were working counter-insurgency? Or
> am I
> being over-romantic?
> Such being the case, the Tokugawa managed toNot really. The Takeda executed a tactical withdrawal,
> manouvre the
> Takeda into overplaying their hand, as it were,
> which might be
> counted as a highly successful ninja operation,
> based on sound
> intelligence rather than assassinations,
> wall-climbings, etc.
> Again, as Paul pointed out an age ago (hi Paul)2 peasants and a monk, actually. THESE are true
> there's a scene
> in Kagemusha where 3 peasants (in the employ of the
> Oda and
> the Tokugawa) are watching 'Shingen' review his
> troops and are
> convinced it is he, which is the report that goes
> back to HQ.
> No doubt Hollywood would have them attempt toExploding Geisha? I'd pay Y1500 for that ticket!
> assassinate
> Shingen with blow darts, exploding geisha, or
> something of that
> ilk.
> Exploding Geisha? I'd pay Y1500 for that ticket!You litterally took the words right out of my mouth!
> Exploding Geisha? I'd pay Y1500 for that ticket!During WWII the Brits wanted to take out some lock gates in
> There may have been intel/counterintell involved (GODAh! but who suborned the Administrator?
> I would love to find data on that...drool) but
> essentially it wasn't a "ninja", but a well placed
> Tokugawa administrator who had agreed to set a fire
> and open the gates to the Takeda army.
> 2 peasants and a monk, actually. THESE are trueIn the Cold War days wasn't 'journalist' the
> "shinobi no mono" or "kusa". I'd LOVE to do research
> on the intell techniques of the sengoku, but man,
> would I have to dig for resources...maybe this new
> Rekishi Gunzo K is talking about...
> Exploding Geisha? I'd pay Y1500 for that ticket!And Tom Cruise could play Shingen!
> I would love to find data on that...drool) butAh! but who suborned the Administrator?
> essentially it wasn't a "ninja", but a well placed
> Tokugawa administrator who had agreed to set a fire
> and open the gates to the Takeda army.
> 2 peasants and a monk, actually. THESE are trueIn the Cold War days wasn't 'journalist' the
> "shinobi no mono" or "kusa". I'd LOVE to do research
> on the intell techniques of the sengoku, but man,
> would I have to dig for resources...maybe this new
> Rekishi Gunzo K is talking about...
> Exploding Geisha? I'd pay Y1500 for that ticket!And Tom Cruise could play Shingen!
> Ah! but who suborned the Administrator?I doubt it was someone dressed in black pajamas. Of
> But I know, I know ... I think the reality is a lotGenerally I find reality more interesting. I'd rather
> more drab and
> dreary than we would like, with the occasional
> flashes of
> adventure!
> In the Cold War days wasn't 'journalist' thePossibly, yeah. However, speaking as a member of the
> common cover? I suppose a Tendai Monk walking the
> streets of Prague or Vienna to the Harry Lime theme
> would have stuck out a bit...
> > Exploding Geisha? I'd pay Y1500 for that ticket!You're trying to give me a heart attack, aren't you?
>
> And Tom Cruise could play Shingen!
> I agree.Tom Cruise would be a perfect Shingen.Thathttp://www.samurai.de/Home_D/Takeda_Shingen/takeda_shingen.html
> reminds me.Is available an accurate picture of
> Shingen?????
>
> Edy
> And please don't say things like "Tom Cruise wouldWatanabe Ken, however...
> be
> a perfect Shingen"...my heart can't take it.
>__________________________________
> > And please don't say things like "Tom Cruise would
> > be
> > a perfect Shingen"...my heart can't take it.
>
> Watanabe Ken, however...
>
>
>
> __________________________________
> Do you Yahoo!?
> New and Improved Yahoo! Mail - Send 10MB messages!
> http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail
>
> I agree.Tom Cruise would be a perfect Shingen.Thathttp://www.samurai.de/Home_D/Takeda_Shingen/takeda_shingen.html
> reminds me.Is available an accurate picture of
> Shingen?????
>
> Edy
> I didn't to say he would be a ""perfect" Shingen.IIf he can't pull off being Irish in "Far and Away", I
> mean,he could be Takeda Shingen in a movie.No one
> will ever be like Shingen.No person will ever be a
> military genius like he was.Thanx for the pictures.
>
> Edy
>
> P.S.:In one picture,Shingen is not wearing the
> armour.Are the Daimyo so fat when they are not
> wearing the armor????
> As for being fat, that's the clothes--just the wayWell, dont forget, this pic:
> they are drawn.
> In fact my interest in the samurai as such is to strip away theI have always thought the reality is so much more amazing than any
> 'warrior myth' - the reality IS far more fantastic, in its way,
> than the legend. The development of swordsmanship becomes
> meaningless (to me) when those involved are demigods. When
> they are simply men ... then that's something else.
> the Sengoku is probably more interesting and epic than mostfiction books could ever hope for...
> I can't remember precisely the where or when, but there was aIt happened (I believe) in 1586, when Hideyoshi was having all of the
> time when Ieyasu went to visit Hideyoshi(?) and a number of
> Hideyoshi's women were the hostages of the Tokugawa.
>
> Sakai used to go and sit with them, chat and pass the time to
> ease their nerves, meanwhile outside Honda was stacking
> firewood against the walls, ready to torch the place if anything
> should happen to his lord. What days!
> Is thought to not even be a picture of Shingen atReally? Hmm. I just typed in 'Takeda Shingen' to
> all. Cant remember
> who it is thought to be though.
>
>
> Really? Hmm. I just typed in 'Takeda Shingen' toI'm sure SOMEONE here knows what I am talking about. I read it in
> google photo search, and picked the few I'd seen
> before. I'd seen that one before ID'd as him. Hmm.
> That's the chap!Totman, Conrad. "Tokugawa Ieyasu, SHOGUN" Union City, California:
>
> BTW - Is there another English-print bio. of Ieyasu besides
> Sadler's?
>
> Thomas
>Along the lines of Sengoku spies, I came across an interesting bit on
> --- Thomas Davidsonwrote:
>
>
> > Ah! but who suborned the Administrator?
>
> I doubt it was someone dressed in black pajamas. Of
> course there were covert messages between Katsuyori
> and said administrator. Incidentally, it's killing me
> that I can't remember his name. For some reason Ota
> Yasusuke sticks in my head, but that's wrong--Yasusuke
> was a Hojo retainer. I'm currently not able to get to
> my crutch, the Turnbull book on Nagashino, and when
> the first hit on Google that comes up is a report that
> I myself wrote (and neglected to mention the name),
> I'm out of luck.
>
> > But I know, I know ... I think the reality is a lot
> > more drab and
> > dreary than we would like, with the occasional
> > flashes of
> > adventure!
>
> Generally I find reality more interesting. I'd rather
> read about how someone bribed the maid of Lord
> so-and-so to gain access to a room where they
> overheard x conversation, then snuck out dressed as a
> monk and such, than to hear some silly story about
> sneaking in dressed in black pajamas, killing guards
> with magical incantations, then disappearing in a
> cloud of smoke. Bah.
> --- In samuraihistory@yahoogroups.com, Nate Ledbetterfar
>wrote:
>
> > Really? Hmm. I just typed in 'Takeda Shingen' to
> > google photo search, and picked the few I'd seen
> > before. I'd seen that one before ID'd as him. Hmm.
>
> I'm sure SOMEONE here knows what I am talking about. I read it in
> one of the books that I dont have with me a few years ago, and
> someone else had mentioned they had heard it to, and even went so
> as to give the name of the person it is thought to be. Again, letus
> rely on strength in numbers - one of the 902 people here must know.