--- ryhorikawa <
ryhorikawa@...> wrote:
I think if you contacted a judan
> kyudo sensei, he
> would probably answer the same way if asked about
> the
> relationship between Zen and kyudo...
He might. However, the point he was trying to make, if
I'm correct, is that not everything in Japanese
culture/life is imbued with Zen, nor is everything in
Japanese history. Zen is a part of, but not the
entirety. Sometimes a duck is just a duck. Zen is a
small percentage of active Buddhist adherents in
Japan. Unfortunately, it receives so much print and
press that many people believe that all Japanese sit
and listen to the rocks grow, or harken to hear the
sound of one hand clapping. This is far from the
truth. Neither must one be a strict adherent of Zen
Buddhism to practice Kendo or Kyudo. Yes, the
philosophy is part of the practice, but they are not
one and the same. Do I have to renounce my
Christianity in order to pick up a shinai? I think
not.
> This might irritate you a bit but it is intended
> with a bit of humor
> and certainly much love: You wrote "bear in mind the
> agendas of
> writers". The goal in Zen is to abandon all agendas.
However, the writers mentioned certainly have a
Zen-biased agenda. That's not a criticism, but an
observation. Their purpose is to promote their image
of Zen.
To me, it is JUST as unfortunate for people to be led
to the misperception that all Japanese practice tea
ceremony and kendo in some sort of mystical Zen quest
as it is for them to think that all samurai followed
bushido and committed seppuku if they coughed wrong.
While Zen captures the Western imagination, even
Tokugawa Ieyasu didn't belong to the Zen sect--he was
a follower of Jodo-shuu. Most samurai didn't study
kenjutsu in preparation for some musha-shugyo where
they found spiritual enlightenment, they did it so
they could kill and keep from being killed on the
battlefield. While Kyudo may have developed as a means
to putting Zen principles into practice, kyujutsu was
developed as a means of putting an arrow into your
enemy.
Regardless, I hope the young person who started all
this is happy--with no effort on his part, we've given
him a lot to think about.
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
New and Improved Yahoo! Mail - 100MB free storage!
http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail